Home › Styles › Traditional › Indiana

Traditional tattoo shops in Indiana

22 tattoo shops in Indiana have customer reviews or their own website that mention traditional work, the most in Evansville (3). They're ranked by Google rating weighted by number of reviews, and under each shop is the review sentence or website note that shows its traditional work.

No. 01 4.6 ★

Evil by the Needle

1500 S Walnut St, Bloomington, IN

Piercing Fine lineTraditional
4.6Rating
490Reviews
2Styles

“The piercer also gave me a paper with my piercing info and gauge size which is great, and there’s a fine line and traditional tattoo artists.” (Google review, Nov 2025)

Mentioned once in reviews

No. 02 4.8 ★

High Caliber Tattoo and Piercing Studio

1005 S Lynhurst Dr, Indianapolis, IN

Cover-ups Piercing TraditionalFine line
4.8Rating
305Reviews
5Styles

Mentioned once in reviews · Per the shop's website

No. 03 4.9 ★

Artistic Outcasts Tattooing

18 Pine Lake Ave, La Porte, IN

Walk-ins Piercing Fine lineTraditional
4.9Rating
185Reviews
6Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 04 4.9 ★

Golden Goose Tattoo Company

5329 W 10th St, Indianapolis, IN

Piercing ColorFine line
4.9Rating
185Reviews
6Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 05 4.9 ★

Take Action Tattoo and Gaming

938 N Detroit St, Warsaw, IN

Walk-ins Cover-ups Piercing Lettering & scriptFine line
4.9Rating
185Reviews
5Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 06 5 ★

Dazzled Ink Fine Line Tattoos

108 S Wayne St, Angola, IN

Piercing Fine lineTraditional
5Rating
165Reviews
2Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 07 4.8 ★

Bluebird Tattoo

6230 Central Ave, Portage, IN

PortraitsTraditional
4.8Rating
188Reviews
7Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 08 4.5 ★

Artistic?

9747 E US Hwy 36, Avon, IN

Piercing TraditionalLettering & script
4.5Rating
255Reviews
2Styles

“Whether it’s black white and grey, American traditional, or something completely different, he can make it happen.” (Google review, Mar 2026)

Mentioned once in reviews

No. 09 4.7 ★

Revolution Ink Studio

117 S Green River Rd, Evansville, IN

Piercing TraditionalBlackwork
4.7Rating
178Reviews
3Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 10 4.6 ★

Revolution Tattoo & Body Modification

329 Northwestern Ave, West Lafayette, IN

Piercing Traditional
4.6Rating
180Reviews
1Styles

“Super friendly outlaw American traditional.” (Google review, Aug 2021)

Mentioned once in reviews

No. 11 4.4 ★

Majestik Creations Tattoo Inc

10030 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN

Walk-ins Piercing Geometric & dotworkTraditional
4.4Rating
203Reviews
2Styles

Mentioned once in reviews

No. 12 4.9 ★

Vault 74 Tattoo, LLC

3130 Meridian Parke Dr Ste E, Greenwood, IN

Walk-ins ColorTraditional
4.9Rating
117Reviews
2Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 13 4.8 ★

The Painted Lady

1305 E State Blvd, Fort Wayne, IN

Cover-ups Piercing Fine lineColor
4.8Rating
120Reviews
3Styles

“She takes her time and does amazing work, if you’re looking for American traditional, she’s your gal!” (Google review, Dec 2023)

Mentioned once in reviews

No. 14 4.5 ★

Jekyll & Hyde Tattoo

above Waleed's International Hair Design, 4901 Tippecanoe Dr 2nd floor, Evansville, IN

Walk-ins Cover-ups Piercing Fine lineTraditional
4.5Rating
134Reviews
4Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 15 4.9 ★

The Secret Garden

425 Main St Ste 12, Evansville, IN

Traditional
4.9Rating
61Reviews
1Styles

“I asked for American traditional with a feminine twist, and she knocked it out of the park!!” (Google review, Jan 2025)

Mentioned once in reviews

No. 16 5 ★

Majestik Creations Tattoo III

Majestik Creations Tattoo III, 1176 N Main St, Franklin, IN

Cover-ups Piercing Traditional
5Rating
50Reviews
1Styles

“Also wound up placing second place in 2 tattoo competitions on the bigger traditional piece 😁” (Google review, Aug 2024)

Mentioned once in reviews

No. 17 4.9 ★

Lucky Dog Tattoo

410 West St, Madison, IN

Cover-ups TraditionalColor
4.9Rating
51Reviews
2Styles

“He does amazing American traditional work but is also talented in other areas as well.” (Google review, Feb 2024)

Mentioned in 2 reviews

No. 18 5 ★

Attraction Tattoos

2624 Maplecrest Rd, Fort Wayne, IN

TraditionalRealism
5Rating
41Reviews
2Styles

“Her realism and traditional work is worth every penny.” (Google review, Aug 2021)

Mentioned once in reviews

No. 19 5 ★

Black Wolf Ink Tattoo & Art Studio

11801 Commercial Dr Studio #5, Fishers, IN

Cover-ups Fine lineTraditional
5Rating
24Reviews
6Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 20 4.5 ★

Dropouts Studio

510 W 4th St, Bloomington, IN

Walk-ins Fine lineTraditional
4.5Rating
26Reviews
4Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 21 5 ★

Heart City Social Club

700 S Main St, Elkhart, IN

Cover-ups TraditionalNeo-traditional
5Rating
11Reviews
2Styles

“The shop has been carefully curated to give that old school traditional tattoo shop vibe, yet elevated.” (Google review, Oct 2026)

Mentioned in 2 reviews · Per the shop's website

No. 22 4.6 ★

La Familia Tattoo

529 W Chicago Ave, East Chicago, IN

TraditionalRealism
4.6Rating
9Reviews
4Styles

Per the shop's website

Map of traditional tattoo shops in Indiana

By city

Counts are traditional shops; each city page lists every tattoo shop there.

About traditional tattoos

Bold black outlines, a small set of solid colors (red, green, yellow, black) and simple shading. Classic images include roses, eagles, panthers, swallows, daggers and anchors. Also called American traditional or old school.

Many shops have several artists, so ask which one does the most traditional work and look at their healed pieces before you book.

All 2,010 traditional tattoo shops → · Every tattoo shop in Indiana →

Other styles in Indiana

Styles, artists and walk-in policies change. Call the shop or check its portfolio before you go.