Home › Styles › Traditional › New Jersey

Traditional tattoo shops in New Jersey

38 tattoo shops in New Jersey have customer reviews or their own website that mention traditional work, the most in Maplewood (2). They're ranked by Google rating weighted by number of reviews, and under each shop is the review sentence or website note that shows its traditional work.

No. 01 4.9 ★

7 Souls Tattoo and Body Piercing Studio

14 S Dean St 2nd Floor, Englewood, NJ

Cover-ups Piercing Fine lineTraditional
4.9Rating
1,220Reviews
4Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 02 4.8 ★

Rock City Tattoos & Body Piercing

400 Washington Ave, Belleville, NJ

Piercing TraditionalBlack and grey
4.8Rating
1,010Reviews
2Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 03 4.9 ★

Blue Bird Tattoo Gallery | Jersey City, NJ

1074 Summit Ave, Jersey City, NJ

Walk-ins Cover-ups Piercing Fine lineTraditional
4.9Rating
686Reviews
4Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 04 5 ★

Etched in Ink Tattoo

770 NJ-15 S, Lake Hopatcong, NJ

Piercing TraditionalNeo-traditional
5Rating
498Reviews
7Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 05 4.9 ★

Pure Ink Tattoo Studio

470 NJ-10, Ledgewood, NJ

Piercing Fine lineTraditional
4.9Rating
483Reviews
7Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 06 4.8 ★

Ink Therapy Tattoo & Piercing

220 Forsgate Dr Unit B, Jamesburg, NJ

Walk-ins Cover-ups Piercing Traditional
4.8Rating
371Reviews
1Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 07 5 ★

American Dream Tattoo

107 Prospect St, Westfield, NJ

Fine lineTraditional
5Rating
248Reviews
9Styles

“After I gave him a general idea of what I wanted during the consultation (American traditional heart) he threw in a couple of aspects personal to me that I wanted and absolutely killed my design!” (Google review, Aug 2026)

Mentioned once in reviews · Per the shop's website

No. 08 4.9 ★

Yours To Keep Tattoo

530 Crown Point Rd, West Deptford, NJ

Walk-ins Cover-ups Piercing Traditional
4.9Rating
194Reviews
1Styles

“I have gotten a bunch of traditional style tattoos from Yours To Keep and each time it’s been a great experience!” (Google review, Dec 2025)

Mentioned once in reviews

No. 09 4.9 ★

North Jersey Tattoo

405 US-46, Rockaway, NJ

TraditionalBlack and grey
4.9Rating
177Reviews
2Styles

“She did an American traditional piece on my back and it came out amazing.” (Google review, Apr 2025)

Mentioned once in reviews

No. 10 4.9 ★

Sinful Art Tattoo

311 N Delsea Dr, Clayton, NJ

Walk-ins RealismColor
4.9Rating
177Reviews
5Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 11 5 ★

The Black Rose

601 Shore Rd Ste C, Somers Point, NJ

Black and greyFine line
5Rating
151Reviews
4Styles

“She did my black and grey American traditional sleeve, and the work is absolutely incredible.” (Google review, Nov 2025)

Mentioned once in reviews

No. 12 4.9 ★

Cardinal Tattoo Studio

5101 NJ-42, Turnersville, NJ

Walk-ins Traditional
4.9Rating
138Reviews
1Styles

“If you want a bold, bright, and beautiful traditional tattoo he’s without a doubt your guy.” (Google review, Feb 2023)

Mentioned in 2 reviews

No. 13 4.9 ★

Moonlight Tattoo

108 NJ-50, Ocean View, NJ

Walk-ins TraditionalNeo-traditional
4.9Rating
127Reviews
8Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 14 4.9 ★

Iron Horse Tattoo

2037 S Black Horse Pike, Williamstown, NJ

Piercing Traditional
4.9Rating
114Reviews
1Styles

“He does great work, especially if you’re into traditional tattoos, and he’s a good guy.” (Google review, Mar 2023)

Mentioned once in reviews

No. 15 4.7 ★

Ink'd Society

120 Georges Rd Unit f, North Brunswick Township, NJ

Walk-ins Piercing Fine lineRealism
4.7Rating
135Reviews
4Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 16 4.7 ★

Ink Bound Tattoo

46 Ferry St, Newark, NJ

Piercing Traditional
4.7Rating
133Reviews
1Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 17 4.9 ★

True Line Tattoo

412 N White Horse Pike, Stratford, NJ

Walk-ins Cover-ups PortraitsTraditional
4.9Rating
105Reviews
2Styles

“She even offered to fix the old school tattoos AND touch up her tattoos that are due for a touch up for a completely fair fee!” (Google review, Jan 2026)

Mentioned once in reviews

No. 18 4.7 ★

Gold Leaf Tattoo

241 W White Horse Pike, Egg Harbor City, NJ

Cover-ups Piercing Fine lineTraditional
4.7Rating
126Reviews
10Styles

Mentioned once in reviews · Per the shop's website

No. 19 4.6 ★

Big Bob's Tattoo World

127 Greentree Rd, Blackwood, NJ

Traditional
4.6Rating
136Reviews
1Styles

“Excellent place, especially if you want the classic tattoo shop experience.” (Google review, May 2026)

Mentioned once in reviews

No. 20 5 ★

Fait Maison

73-87 Clay St Retail # 3, Newark, NJ

ColorFine line
5Rating
84Reviews
8Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 21 5 ★

Sink or Swim Tattoo Parlor

950 Atlantic City Blvd Ste 12, Bayville, NJ

TraditionalBlack and grey
5Rating
77Reviews
2Styles

“Sink or Swim Tattoo Parlor is one of the only places in the country where you can get the highest quality American Traditional tattoos done in black and gray by an expert artist.” (Google review, Jun 2025)

Mentioned in 3 reviews

No. 22 4.7 ★

Under Skin Art

8 Palisade Ave, Bergenfield, NJ

Fine lineTraditional
4.7Rating
101Reviews
7Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 23 5 ★

Historic Custom Tattoo

700 Somerset St, Watchung, NJ

Cover-ups Fine lineTraditional
5Rating
74Reviews
3Styles

“A true real deal old school tattoo shop.” (Google review, Oct 2026)

Mentioned in 2 reviews

No. 24 4.7 ★

Pretty In Ink

191 Hamburg Tpke, Pompton Lakes, NJ

Walk-ins TraditionalFine line
4.7Rating
92Reviews
4Styles

“She's now done both my permanent eyeliner and a traditional tattoo for me and I suggest her studio to everyone I talk to about tattoos.” (Google review, Apr 2021)

Mentioned once in reviews · Per the shop's website

No. 25 4.9 ★

EQ Tattoo

Southwood Shopping Center, 875 Mantua Pike Ste 10, West Deptford, NJ

Walk-ins Cover-ups Piercing RealismBlack and grey
4.9Rating
71Reviews
8Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 26 5 ★

Funtown Tattoo

2433 Bridge Ave, Point Pleasant, NJ

Traditional
5Rating
64Reviews
1Styles

“Funtown Tattoo has that traditional tattoo atmosphere and is super clean.” (Google review, Dec 2023)

Mentioned once in reviews

No. 27 4.7 ★

Crown & Anchor Tattoo Parlor

626 NJ-88, Point Pleasant, NJ

WatercolorTraditional
4.7Rating
80Reviews
10Styles

Mentioned once in reviews · Per the shop's website

No. 28 5 ★

Classic Tattoo Club Metuchen

327 Main St, Metuchen, NJ

TraditionalColor
5Rating
54Reviews
2Styles

Mentioned in 3 reviews

No. 29 4.8 ★

Circle Of Fire Tattoo

24 US-46, Wayne, NJ

PortraitsTraditional
4.8Rating
63Reviews
3Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 30 4.9 ★

Central Avenue Tattoo

9-15 Central Sta, Flemington, NJ

TraditionalJapanese
4.9Rating
56Reviews
2Styles

Mentioned in 2 reviews

No. 31 4.5 ★

Tattoo Connection

205 NJ-23, Wantage, NJ

Walk-ins Piercing Traditional
4.5Rating
75Reviews
1Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 32 4.9 ★

Tattoo Love Shack

1779 Springfield Ave, Maplewood, NJ

Walk-ins Cover-ups Piercing TraditionalBlack and grey
4.9Rating
48Reviews
3Styles

Mentioned once in reviews · Per the shop's website

No. 33 5 ★

Anchors Aweigh Tattoo

712 Main St, Bradley Beach, NJ

Cover-ups Traditional
5Rating
44Reviews
1Styles

“I love big, bold, traditional tattoos, and he does them so well, along with other styles.” (Google review, Dec 2019)

Mentioned once in reviews

No. 34 4.5 ★

45 Monks Tattoo

241 Old Bridge Tpke, East Brunswick, NJ

Walk-ins Piercing Fine lineTraditional
4.5Rating
63Reviews
8Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 35 4.6 ★

Unwritten Ink

152 Washington Rd Apt 1, Sayreville, NJ

TraditionalRealism
4.6Rating
46Reviews
2Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 36 4.8 ★

On The Grind Tattoo

571 Berlin - Cross Keys Rd Ste 101, Sicklerville, NJ

PortraitsBlack and grey
4.8Rating
36Reviews
9Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 37 4.3 ★

Fat Kats Tattoo

3723 Ventnor Ave, Atlantic City, NJ

Cover-ups Black and greyPortraits
4.3Rating
55Reviews
5Styles

Per the shop's website

No. 38 5 ★

Brandon Lee Tattoo's

155 Maplewood Ave, Maplewood, NJ

Traditional
5Rating
4Reviews
1Styles

Per the shop's website

Map of traditional tattoo shops in New Jersey

By city

Counts are traditional shops; each city page lists every tattoo shop there.

About traditional tattoos

Bold black outlines, a small set of solid colors (red, green, yellow, black) and simple shading. Classic images include roses, eagles, panthers, swallows, daggers and anchors. Also called American traditional or old school.

Many shops have several artists, so ask which one does the most traditional work and look at their healed pieces before you book.

All 2,010 traditional tattoo shops → · Every tattoo shop in New Jersey →

Other styles in New Jersey

Styles, artists and walk-in policies change. Call the shop or check its portfolio before you go.