Home › Tattoo and piercing shops › New York › New Hartford

Tattoo and piercing shops in New Hartford, NY

3 tattoo shops in New Hartford do piercing too, out of 8 shops we list in the city. We list a tattoo shop here only when customer reviews mention piercing there, its Google listing includes a piercing category, or its own website offers piercing. Sorted by Google rating, weighted by the number of reviews.

Piercers often keep their own schedule, separate from the tattoo artists. Call to check a piercer is in and ask about their policy for ID and minors.

No. 01 4.6 ★

Bodily Charm Tattoo & Piercing

4679 Commercial Dr, New Hartford, NY

Cover-ups Piercing Fine line
4.6Rating
168Reviews
1Styles

“She was extremely thorough in making sure I was comfy, happy with the piercing placement, and explained important points about the piercing I was getting.” (Google review, Nov 2025)

Listed on Google as a piercing shop too · Per the shop's website · Piercing mentioned 41 times in reviews

No. 02 3.9 ★

Rockin' Horse Tattoo & Piercing

8441 Seneca Tpke, New Hartford, NY

Piercing
3.9Rating
286Reviews
—Styles

“I ended up losing a ball from my septum piercing and within only a few minutes I was seated in the chair and getting it replaced.” (Google review, Jan 2020)

Piercing mentioned 27 times in reviews

No. 03 5 ★

Pierce it or Ink it V

8555 Seneca Tpke Ste D12, New Hartford, NY

Piercing
5Rating
26Reviews
—Styles

“I will definitely be coming back for my next piercing & tattoo — 10/10 recommend!” (Google review, Oct 2026)

Piercing mentioned 13 times in reviews

Map of tattoo and piercing shops in New Hartford

Before you get pierced

  1. Call ahead. Piercers often work different hours from the tattoo artists, so check one is in.
  2. Ask about the jewelry. Ask what the jewelry for a new piercing is made of and whether it's priced separately. Tell the piercer about any metal allergy.
  3. Bring a photo ID. Rules for piercing minors vary by state and by shop. Check the shop's policy before you go.
  4. Follow the aftercare. Your piercer will tell you how to look after it. If it gets very red, swollen, hot or painful, see a doctor.

More on getting pierced at a tattoo shop.

Tattoo and piercing shops in nearby cities