Home › New York › Staten Island › What's Up Your Sleeve? Tattoo Shop & Gallery

What's Up Your Sleeve? Tattoo Shop & Gallery Tattoo shop in Staten Island, NY

5 ★★★★★ 134 Google reviews

Cover-ups WatercolorRealism

What's Up Your Sleeve? Tattoo Shop & Gallery is a tattoo shop at 844 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, NY. It has a 5-star rating from 134 Google reviews. Customer reviews or the shop's own website mention watercolor and realism work.

Styles

Each style is listed only when a customer review or the shop's own website mentions it. Ask to see healed work in the style you want.

  • “The space was super clean, communication was easy, and he did an amazing watercolor raven design that completely transformed the area.” (Google review, May 2025)

    Mentioned 2 times in reviews

  • “The colors, the movement, and the realism of these two betta fish are absolutely beautiful.” (Google review, Jul 2026)

    Mentioned once in reviews

What clients say

  • Cover-ups

    “He’s clearly talented and handled the cover-up with a lot of care and skill.” (Google review, May 2025)

    Mentioned 2 times in reviews

  • Custom designs

    “You took the time to sit with me, listen to my ideas, and turned my vision into a true masterpiece.” (Google review, Jul 2026)

    Mentioned once in reviews

  • Clean studio

    “The space was super clean, communication was easy, and he did an amazing watercolor raven design that completely transformed the area.” (Google review, May 2025)

    Mentioned 8 times in reviews

More shops that do cover-ups →

From Google reviews

This was my first time coming and I definitely will be coming back for my future tattoos! Not only was the environment comfortable and clean, but it was also nice to have someone listen to what you want and give you an honest opinion rather than giving you something you may not like. I definitely recommend this place!

★★★★★ Elizabeth, Oct 2026

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I can’t thank you enough for the incredible work you did on this tattoo. This wasn’t just another tattoo it was a tribute to my brother and his love for betta fish. You took the time to sit with me, listen to my ideas, and turned my vision into a true masterpiece.

★★★★★ Jorge, Jul 2026

Excerpts from public Google reviews. We leave out reviews that name an artist. Read all 134 on Google →

Where to find What's Up Your Sleeve? Tattoo Shop & Gallery

More tattoo shops nearby

Staten Island, NY 4.6 ★

House of Misfits Tattoo

819 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, NY

Cover-ups Piercing Fine lineRealism
4.6Rating
91Reviews
4Styles

Under a mile away

Staten Island, NY 4.7 ★

Bound For Glory Tattoo

607 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY

Walk-ins Piercing
4.7Rating
276Reviews
—Styles

Under a mile away

Staten Island, NY 4.8 ★

Ink-U-2 LLC

245 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY

Piercing
4.8Rating
148Reviews
—Styles

Under a mile away

Staten Island, NY 4.4 ★

Firme Tattoo Art Shop

105 Port Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY

4.4Rating
25Reviews
—Styles

1.2 miles away

Staten Island, NY 5 ★

Jus Lily NYC

412 Manor Rd, Staten Island, NY

Piercing
5Rating
10Reviews
—Styles

1.4 miles away

Bayonne, NJ 4.8 ★

Industrial Art Tattoo

3 W 8th St, Bayonne, NJ

Piercing
4.8Rating
219Reviews
—Styles

1.6 miles away

All tattoo shops in Staten Island, NY →

Tattoo shops in nearby cities

All tattoo shops in New York →

Independent listing, not affiliated with this shop. Details come from public business info, customer reviews and the shop's own website. Confirm hours and walk-in policy before you go.

Something out of date? Send a correction. Own this shop? Update your listing. It's free.